NY, US · AI law tracker
A10583 — NY, US
A10583 is an AI governance legislation from NY, currently committee. This bill would prohibit New York state entities from using AI for decisions impacting individual rights or services [1]. AIGI tracks 1 primary-source update on this bill; the most recent was published on 2024-06-20.
Status & timeline
- Regulatory stage
- committee
- Bill status
- In Assembly Committee
- Authority / governing body
- New York State Senate
- Chamber
- Assembly
- Document type
- legislation
Next deadline: No fixed deadline — bill remains in committee.
Subscriber only
Full obligation matrix
| Actor | Obligation | Deadline | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| deployer | State agencies and state-owned entities shall not utilize large language models or any artificial intelligence systems to make decisions that affect individuals' rights, benefits, or services. | null | — |
| deployer | State agencies and state-owned entities must ensure that decisions affecting individuals' rights, benefits, or services are made by human personnel. | null | — |
Subscriber only
Enforcement risk score
Announced regulation; enforcement footprint still forming.
Subscriber only
Role-based compliance checklist
- compliance_officer Identify all existing and planned AI systems used by the agency/entity for making decisions that affect individuals' rights, benefits, or services.
- cto Evaluate current AI deployments and operational models to determine potential non-compliance if the bill is enacted.
- general_counsel Review the bill's language and scope to understand the full implications for the agency/entity's AI usage policies.
- board_director Begin strategizing potential changes to AI procurement and deployment policies to align with mandated human oversight requirements.
Subscriber only
Vendor impact assessment
- Vendor risk class
- high
- Procurement categories
- hr_tech, customer_service_ai, fraud_detection, financial_decisions, healthcare_ai, other
Vendors providing AI solutions to New York state agencies or state-owned entities will face high impact. Their products must either not automate decisions concerning individuals' rights, benefits, or services, or be adaptable to ensure human personnel maintain absolute decision-making authority in such contexts.
Sample vendor questions
- Does your AI system make or significantly influence decisions affecting individuals' rights, benefits, or services when deployed within a state agency?
- Can your AI system be configured to function solely as an assistive tool for human decision-makers, ensuring human personnel retain final decision-making authority?
- What mechanisms are in place within your AI solution to facilitate transparent human oversight and intervention in critical decisions?
Intelligence briefs (1)
NY Bill A10583 Proposes Ban on State Agency AI for Individual Decisions
This bill would prohibit New York state entities from using AI for decisions impacting individual rights or services [1].
This development signals a potential shift in public sector AI deployment constraints and accountability frameworks in New York.
Deadline: No fixed deadline — bill remains in committee.
Primary source →Frequently asked questions
- What is A10583?
- New York Assembly Bill A10583 seeks to prohibit state agencies and state-owned entities from employing large language models or any artificial intelligence systems to make decisions impacting individuals' rights, benefits, or services [1]. The bill mandates that human personnel from the respective entities must make such determinations, outlining specific exceptions and enforcement mechanisms [2]. This legislative initiative is currently under review within the Assembly's Science and Technology Committee. Primary source →
- Why does A10583 matter?
- This development signals a potential shift in public sector AI deployment constraints and accountability frameworks in New York. Primary source →
- Who does A10583 affect?
- This proposed legislation directly impacts New York state agencies and state-owned entities that currently deploy or plan to deploy AI systems, particularly large language models, for decision-making processes affecting individuals. Use cases involving public benefits administration, licensing, or other services where AI might make determinations about individual entitlements or rights are within scope. This also extends to contractors or third-party providers working with these state entities on AI-powered solutions. Primary source →
- What are the key dates for A10583?
- No fixed deadline — bill remains in committee. Primary source →
- What is the current status of A10583?
- As of the last published update, A10583 is at the "committee" stage, with bill status "In Assembly Committee". Primary source →
- Where can I find the primary source for A10583?
- The primary source for the most recent update is at https://legislation.nysenate.gov/bills/2023/A10583. AIGI publishes the full citation chain plus every approved brief on this bill. Primary source →
Related
Stay informed